Upon reading this article in the NY Times, after a suggestion from a dear friend who understands my love of all things bourbon and 1960’s, I reflected upon my struggle with ordering my favorite cocktail in any kind of public dining arena. The Old Fashioned, which is featured in the above linked article, has the claim to fame of being one of the very first drinks to be called a “cocktail.” It’s roots date back to the early 1800’s but the recipe that is closest to what is the (best) way to make an Old Fashioned was concocted in the 1880’s in Louisville, Kentucky. Early in my beverage consumption history, I frequently ordered Old Fashioneds while in restaurants, bars, clubs, casinos etc…and frequently what I received in return for my $10.00 was something far from an Old Fashioned. Once I received a Old Fashioned made with Brandy…barf! Another time I received an Old Fashioned with no fruit, aka: a watered down Manhattan. And most recently, I ordered an Old Fashioned that had so much soda water in it it was translucent. This is the first sign of a bartender who has no clue what they are doing…. In fact, only twice have I order an Old Fashioned that came to me in a manner that I found at all acceptable. Once was at bar at Mohegan Sun with my besties. The Second was, and still is, my favorite Old Fashioned. Ever. You must be wondering, where is this fine dining establishment that serves such a delectable spirit? Well, Internet: it’s my Dad’s house.
It is from my father that I learned, or am genetically pre-disposed to, my love of Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey. I have fond memories of evenings around a campfire eating Bourbon Balls that my father’s friends would bring on our camping outings, of the smell of Henry McKenna on his breath when he kissed me good night and of the marinated cherry he would let me have when his drink was finally empty. Ironically, this is also my daughter’s favorite treat as well….hmmm…..
I will start by sharing with you all the family secret recipe that has been passed through one whole generation….from my father to me, then fill you in one other variations which you could possibly end up with when ordering an old fashioned, thereby completely ruining the rest of your evening.
First off, The Your Average Mom’s Dad’s Old Fashioned.
Start with one Old Fashioned Glass
Now, the shape pf the glass is important, the bottom should be open, not narrow, as that will impede your muddling maneuvers later on. Also, a nice heavy glass just feels good in the hand….
In your old fashioned glass, you place a round slice of lemon, of orange and a maraschino cherry, a little less then a teaspoon of dark brown sugar, a dash of Angostura Bitters. We have experimented with different types and producers of bitters, but have always found that the best choice was the old standby produced by Angostura who get their bitters from Trinidad and Tobago. Once you master the recipe, feel free to experiment!
Once your hardware is in your glass, you will need a cocktail muddler.
With your muddler, you mash all the above ingredients together. This is a key step and you shouldn’t be too hasty in your muddling. Take your time, get out all the juice and citrus oils from the fruit and allow the sugar to dissolve in the fruit juice.
Once you have muddled your ingredients into a nice pulp, fill your glass with ice cubes. If I have the luxury of crushed ice, I prefer that but honestly, I don’t have an ice machine in my fridge and usually I am just too impatient to crush the ice myself!
After the glass is full, fill it with Jim Beam Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey. My father and I disagree as to the best bourbon for the job. I prefer Jim Beam, as it is a bit sweeter and smoother, but my father prefers Henry McKenna. You can feel free to try both and choose the one you like best, but if it’s not Jim Beam then you have tastebuds made of plastic that’s okay. Don’t be fooled by the pricier bourbons either (I’m looking at you! Maker’s Mark with your fancy wax cork!!). I’ve tried many varietals and the only one that is as close to as delicious as Jim Beam is Booker’s.
Now, stir. Ta da! You’ve just made the N****n Old Fashioned! Congratulations! Now sit back, turn on the PGA Tour, kick your feet up and enjoy your Old Fashioned as my father and I would….
As far things to be careful for when ordering your Old Fashioned:
1. Water, soda or otherwise. This will water down the flavor of the bourbon and KILL this drink. Just don’t do it. Ever. Seriously, I’ll find you and remove your bourbon from that unsafe environment.
2. Any kind of whiskey other then Bourbon. This drink simply is incompatible with most whiskeys, especially a scotch. Bleh! Always make certain to order a Bourbon Old Fashioned because even though the recipe specifies bourbon, many bartenders are unfamiliar with this recipe and might screw it up.
With this information I send thee forth to test the waters (NOT IN THE OLD FASHIONED!!) of the classic Old Fashioned Cocktail. Next time your faced with a drink order, I reccomend passing on that fruity girlie drink and order a cocktail that has been around for over 100 years.
Good Old Fashioned:
Notice the dark color of the Bourbon, and lots of ice….
Bad Old Fashioned:
The color is all wrong and there is FOAM?!?! This is indictative of a cocktail made wth soda water = crappy Old Fashioned. Run away…run far, far away.
Cheers!